Last year, I posted a rant about a book called "The Rainbow Fish" reproduced here in its entirety:
I just re-read Sadie's copy of "The Rainbow Fish" book while I was sorting things for the yard sale. It's supposed to be about sharing. The little fish is covered in shiny scales and all of the other fish want his shiny scales because they don't have any. At first he doesn't give them away, but then he realizes he's all alone and doesn't have any friends. A wise old octopus tells him, "Give away your shiny scales. You won't be as beautiful, but you will have friends." So the rainbow fish gives away all but one of his shiny scales so that EVERY fish has exactly one shiny scale.
Several Morals
1. Redistribution of wealth is good.
2. Individuality is bad.
3. Personal property? How selfish of you!
Is there a sharing and vanity component? Sure, but if the author didn't intend to promote the aformentioned ideals, he certainly did a great job of stupidly stumbling upon them...LOTS of people love this book. I'm sure it's the sharing and vanity component...
In stark contrast, Sadie and I watched the movie "The Incredibles" together tonight while folding clothes...complain about it if you want, but it's probably my favorite kids movie of the last decade. My very favorite theme can be summed up in a couple of key quotes:
(Talking about Dash's particular gifts...he's a superhero)
Helen Parr (to her son): "Everyone's special, Dash."
Dash: "Which is another way of saying no one is."
Later...(talking about Dash's promotion ceremony from 4th grade to 5th grade)
Bob: "They keep creating new ways to celebrate mediocrity."
Yes, yes, we're all unique. Yes, yes, I believe everyone is created with gifts and talents...but not everyone uses them. Not to start a debate here, but I want Sadie to know it usually takes hard work to be "special," and that you can't just be conferred the title because you exist. DO something, MAKE something, BE something...don't just sit around and expect people to swoon over your specialness (well...I'll probably swoon over her 'specialness' regardless of what she does, but that's because I'm a mommy). People should succeed because they have done something to deserve success, not...well...just because. I don't want my sweet baby girl to have an advantage just because she's a girl, I want her to show all those boys how it's done...and with class.
The Incredibles - staying in the video library 'til we wear it out...then we're buying a new copy
"The Rainbow Fish" - relegated to the yard sale pile - $0.50 - barely used - any takers? :)
---
"The Rainbow Fish" is, of course, long gone - it hit the yard sale the next month (though I'm sad that some other child has to hear the nonsense it contains). We're continuing to wear out "The Incredibles" on a fairly regular basis.
Almost a year later, I still find myself pretty cautious about what goes into my daughter's impressionable little head. I'm not opposed to her seeing or hearing things that I disagree with, but while she's little, her brain is my responsibility. I'm not going to be careless with it.
Tonight, while reading "Wacky Wednesday" (on an otherwise normal Wednesday), I remembered that there are a couple of books that I "alter" a little so that they will more closely align with how I want to raise her.
One, in particular, called "Rock-a-Baby Band" is an annoying little rhyming book that she finds fascinating. She has almost the entire book memorized! We read it all except for the very purposeful subtraction of one word...
I know the author put this word in fairly innocently...I'm sure it wasn't to keep the rhythm of the rhymes in the book (because there's no rhythm in the rest of it), but I'm guessing that "rocker babies" are supposed to be at least a little rebellious. Not my kid. Sure, she'll rebel, but I want her to figure out how to do that without my assistance. I can just picture putting her down for a nap one day and hearing her sweet little voice say, "but, Mommy, 'rockers don't take naps!'" HA! I'm keen to just avoid that day all together.
Another book, "What is a Princess?," is one of those Disney early reader books. It's a great little book. She's learned to recognize quite a few words because of it. So...what is a princess?
A princess is kind
A princess is smart
A princess is caring
A princess likes to dress up
A princess is brave
A princess is ready for fun
A princess loves to see new things
A princess is a dreamer
A princess is polite
A princess loves to sing and dance
A princess always lives happily ever after
Ok - not all of these are entirely virtuous, and I don't really have a problem with any of them as they are written, per se...I think they're all ok things to aspire to (especially kindness, intelligence, bravery, politeness...). It's just that "A princess is ready for fun," a seemingly innocuous phrase, becomes whatever the opposite of innocuous is when it's paired with this fantastic picture:

(I added the extra text, of course).
I don't know what it is about the image paired with the words in this book...I'm totally fine with the entire movie scene. I'm fine with Sadie watching that entire movie scene - it really is quite innocent. There's just something about Jasmine escaping with Aladdin to have fun without the context of the movie that seems a little...well...slutty. I'm sure I'm reading too much into it (tee hee), but what if I'm not? If it's my responsibility to send her the right messages now, is this one I want to send?
We just skip this page completely.
In other news, I finished Sadie's alphabet book...a book I'm perfectly happy to have her read every page of.
...and shopping
is virtuous when you do it with Nana. Just in case you were wondering.
As for our fun read of the night, "Wacky Wednesday" (a book in which no words or pages are skipped at our house)...Can you find all 20 Wacky things wrong in this picture? Patrolman McGann says when you do, you can go to bed. I found them all...guess where I'm headed?